A Diamond in the Rough Radiates

A remodel invigorates a tired layout for a Manhattan family

Laura and Randy almost walked away from the Upper East Side co-op that they would live in with their daughter, Morgan, but a second look changed their minds. Everything had felt cramped—the kitchen, the hallways, even the unit’s five closets—but in a fit of inspiration, they discovered that the apartment had potential. They turned to Sweeten, posted their project, and found a general contractor they felt was the right fit for them.

Sweeten matches home renovation projects with vetted general contractors, offering guidance, tools, and support—for free.

Come see how they opened their kitchen to include a built-in desk niche, created seven closets, and enlarged a foyer with a wallpaper-covered ceiling.

living room and entrywayGuest blog post by Sweeten homeowner Laura

We had been living in a Junior 4 (bedroom, kitchen, living room, convertible dining area) that we rented since our daughter was born. We thought we’d live in the apartment for a few years but ended up staying for 10 years. By that point, we had completely outgrown the space, including the dining room converted into a bedroom for our daughter and a dated and closed-off kitchen. It lacked a second full bathroom and closet space, too. Ultimately, we needed a space that felt like ours.

family portraitdining roomliving roomWhen we started our search in January 2017, we looked at a number of apartments. Among our list of must-haves: quiet, two bedrooms, two baths, a kitchen that could be opened up, closet space, a nice building, and great natural light. When we first saw our apartment in May, we only had 15 minutes to go through it, and while I thought it could work better than any we’d seen before (thanks to the amazing natural light and rare east/west exposure), there were some things we’d need to change. My husband felt it wasn’t going to fit our needs. Even though it was a 1,250-square-foot apartment, he thought the kitchen was too tight, that there weren’t enough closets (only five and most of them on the smaller size), and there was a lack of hallways. He just had an overall sense that the space felt too small.

dining space or breakfast nook with pastel green walls and window before renovationkitchenkitchen deskkitchen

I could understand his point. The previous owner lived in the space by herself and had made the second bedroom a closet. The master bath only had a bathtub, the kitchen was narrow (we wondered if the dishwasher could pull all the way down), and the dining room had large pieces of furniture and built-ins extending from the dining to living room, that made the space feel smaller.

I started to look at other co-op apartments in the building with the same floor plan for inspiration and found one that had just undergone a renovation. Based on its layout, I was able to visualize how we could reconfigure the space to add longer hallways, more closets, and a larger kitchen that utilized more of the space. After showing my husband, and revisiting the space a day later, he agreed and we put in an offer. Another family also put in an offer the same day, but ours ended up getting accepted.

kitchen with white cabinets and hardwood floors before renovationkitchen

Ahead of our August close, we started to interview contractors to scope out the work based on our budget. We interviewed two contractors from friend and family recommendations and another that my husband found through his online search that led him to Sweeten.

We were matched with a Sweeten contractor who quickly reached out to us. After an on-site meeting with him, we knew this general contractor was the right match for our projectWe immediately felt excited about his enthusiasm and ideas and worked together to design a floor plan that made sense to us.

Then we went through the long, dreaded wait for permits and the board approval process. It took us through the month of December to get approved so we could proceed with our renovation. During this time, however, we were able to review countless inspiration photos and decide what and how we wanted the space to look and feel.

kitchen stovekitchenBy far, the most complex and difficult decision throughout the project was how to design and create the ideal kitchen. We had two columns that were structural, a steel beam that couldn’t come down, and an electric panel that could prevent us from building out the kitchen entry wall. We wanted to somehow open the kitchen and add an island, but it just didn’t seem feasible. So in our initial plan, we would extend the kitchen but keep it enclosed, and then relocate the electric box outside the kitchen so we could add storage and counter space on that entry wall.

She had her heart set on a window bench where she could sit and read. We were able to add these and create storage opportunities underneath.

Renovate to live, Sweeten to thrive!

Sweeten brings homeowners an exceptional renovation experience by personally matching trusted general contractors to your project, while offering expert guidance and support—at no cost to you.

Start your renovation

On the day before the demo, we decided to forgo a separate dining room space, extend the kitchen, and add an island and bar stools. We would leverage the living space for both the living and dining rooms and the island would be a focal point tying both rooms together. This would allow an open concept space for meals and entertaining.

hallway beforefoyerentrywayWe were also able to add a wine cooler and a designated desk space for the days we work from home and for our daughter to do her homework. We created 40+ cabinets for storage, including a sponge pull-down drawer, two pantry closets, spice racks, and tons of drawers, including for knives and one to fit large silverware. This is probably our favorite room.

living room and foyerhallwaymaster bedroombedroom closet

We knew we wanted to extend the entryway as it was incredibly narrow with two closets on either side of the front door. We decided to keep the larger walk-in and remove the smaller one and create a place that was pretty but also functional.

Since we were removing an entry closet that meant we only had four closets; we needed to solve for this. In the master bedroom, we extended our room into the hallway to enlarge the one small closet that was there and then by closing another space (and relocating the master bath door) build a second walk-in closet. A hallway closet that paralleled another closet was extended both of which would hold linens and utility items.

bedroombedroom desk and window seatIn our daughter’s room, we changed a closet door to open from inside the room instead of the hallway giving her one closet. Then by adding a new double door closet, we were able to give her two additional closets and eliminate the need for a dresser. She also had her heart set on a window bench where she could sit and read. We were able to add these and create storage opportunities underneath.  We now had seven decent-sized closets in the home which suited our storage needs much better.

bedroombedroom drawerThe bathroom is small but we were able to convert the bathtub into a walk-in shower with three different shower heads and update all the tile. A large medicine cabinet and a vanity with four drawers that fit around the pipes provided more storage. As a splurge, we added a towel warmer.

bathroom beforebathroom

The demo started just after the new year and lasted through mid-April. During the project, we tried to be quick and diligent about making decisions, allowing us to complete the renovation close to on schedule. Working with our Sweeten contractor was great and we were able to add some fun design elements that kept with the style including wallpaper in three places and a mirrored barn door for a master closet door.

window seat

Since we’ve moved in, we worked with a decorator on the finishing touches including rugs, lighting, and artwork and have made our new space really feel like home. We’ve now settled in and couldn’t be happier with the outcome!

Thank you, Laura, Morgan, and Randy, for sharing your family home with us! 

LIVING AREA RESOURCES: Engineered wood floors: PID Floors. Interior decorating: Get Decorated.

KITCHEN RESOURCES: Shaker-style cabinets: Custom from general contractor. Cabinet hardware: Amazon. Quartz countertops and backsplash: CompacSink: Kraus. Faucet: GroheRefrigerator, dishwasher, wine cooler, and stove: KitchenAidRegina Andrew Design pendant lighting: Neiman MarcusWAC Track lighting by WAC Lighting: Build.com. Paint in White Heron, #OC 57: Benjamin Moore. Bar stools: CB2. Desk niche wallpaper: Seabrook

BATHROOM RESOURCES: Carrara marble floor and wall tile: Tiles by Kia, Long Island City, NY. Shower fixtures, toilet, and vanity: KohlerSink: FrescaMedicine cabinet: Jacuzzi. Paint in Paper White, #OC-55: Benjamin Moore

MASTER BEDROOM RESOURCES: Regina Andrew Design sconce lighting: Neiman Marcus. Chandelier: West Elm. Wallpaper in Bermuda Hemp in Elephant #5260: Phillip Jeffries

DAUGHTER’S BEDROOM RESOURCES: Sconces: Rejuvenation. Ceiling light fixture: West Elm. Paint in Mint Spritzer, #7005-11: Valspar.

FOYER RESOURCES: Wallpaper by ThinkNoirWallpaper: EtsyLight fixture: West Elm.

A renovation on Central Park West started as an emergency but ended with a happy result.

Sweeten handpicks the best general contractors to match each project’s location, budget, scope, and style. Follow the blog, Sweeten Stories, for renovation ideas and inspiration and when you’re ready to renovate, start your renovation on Sweeten

You may also like

Renovate with Sweeten!


We’ll match you with vetted general contractors and offer support until your project is done — at no cost to you!

Start your renovation

Customer review 5.0


“Sweeten made choosing a trusted contractor feel easy and less daunting. I also appreciated the support when I had questions or concerns.”

— Julia M. from Somerset, NJ

Read more reviews —>
Start your renovation

Subscribe to our
renovation newsletter