Adding a Fireplace to your Renovation: Gas and Wood-burning Go Head to Head

by Serena Solomon

Fireplaces are in demand for Philadelphia renovations, according to Sweeten Expert Dennis, a general contractor who works on about a dozen projects each year that involve fireplace additions, conversions, or restorations. The best time to add a fireplace (or switch from wood-burning to gas) is in the midst of a larger renovation or addition to your home. However, a fireplace can be added to most houses at any time with varying degrees of difficulty. The question is will you go with wood-burning or gas? Depending on what you want to get out of your new fireplace, here are some elements to consider.

wood-burning and gas fireplace

Cost

Masonry for both a chimney and fireplace, plus the added complexities of structural work, can add up to $20,000 to your renovation bill for a wood-burning fireplace, according to Dennis. The cost of a gas fireplace can be as little as $5,000 if your building is already fed with either propane or natural gas, and you’re happy with a metal box fireplace that is prefabricated. If you need to run gas lines to your home or install a propane tank, this could double your bill to more than $10,000. But that’s still a lot less than a wood-burning fireplace.

Winner on cost? Go with gas.

Heat

Not all fires are equal when it comes to the heat they can offer. An enclosed wood-burning stove will warm you up much more than its open hearth or gas cousins. An enclosed stove is also more efficient and will burn less wood. Gas fireplaces add more for aesthetics than heat, but are kinder on the environment than wood-burning ones.

Winner on heat? Go with wood.

Aesthetics

Look and function may be equally important to you when a fireplace is the focal point of a room. If you’re after a nostalgic feel (and distinctive scent), there’s nothing better than an open hearth and wood-burning fireplace with a traditional mantle. Gas fireplaces often come with a wood-like formation of steel or ceramics to give the appearance of a real fire, but do not approximate the kind of broad, full, crackling fire that natural wood provides.

Winner on aesthetics? Go with wood.

Permits

Complicated and time-consuming, permits can pause any project. A wood-burning fire (whether it’s an open hearth or something more along the lines of a potbelly stove) will likely require a building permit because of structural elements like installing the chimney. When the installation of a wood-burning fireplace is part of a larger renovation project that will already require a building permit, you can roll the additional permit need into your process more easily. But if you aren’t planning a major renovation that already calls for permits, pursuing one just for a fireplace might be unnecessarily complicated.

If your gas fireplace is a simple prefabricated box and if gas lines already run to your home, there’s a chance the project won’t require any permits at all, according to Dennis. However, if there are no pre-existing lines and you’re after the open hearth look of a real fire, you will likely need a building permit for the structural work involved, a plumbing permit for the gas line work, and a mechanical permit for work affecting the heating system of your home.

Winner on permits? Close, but probably gas.

Convenience

While some people might enjoy the ritual of lighting fires, a gas fireplace turns on with the flick of a switch. There is no wood to store, no matches needed, and no soot to clean up, according to Dennis. Installing a gas fireplace will also eliminate that stale campfire smell the next morning.

Winner on convenience? Go with gas.

Overall, it’s a pretty even match-up. Gas wins on cost and convenience and wood comes out ahead on look and feel. Let us know in the comments if you went one way or the other!

Sweeten handpicks the best general contractors to match each project’s location, budget, scope, and style. Follow the blog for renovation ideas and inspiration and when you’re ready to renovate, start your renovation on Sweeten.

Explore other stories