Side-by-Side Comparison of Hurricane Shutters and Impact Windows

by Gil Gacuma October 8, 2024

As the frequency and intensity of hurricanes continue to rise due to the climate crisis, protecting your home from these natural disasters is crucial. Hurricane shutters and impact windows are two popular options for hurricane protection. Each has its own unique advantages and disadvantages, and the best choice for you will depend on factors such as your budget, lifestyle, and the specific risks your home faces. In this post, we’ll delve into the key differences between these two options, helping you make an informed decision to safeguard your home and family.

Hurricane shutters

Hurricane shutters are external coverings that are installed over your windows and doors. They can be made of various materials, including wood, aluminum, or vinyl. There are several types of shutters, including accordion shutters, Bahama shutters, and roll-down shutters.

Pros of hurricane shutters:

Cost-effective: Shutters are generally more affordable than impact windows, especially for larger homes.
Versatile: They can be used on a variety of window and door sizes and styles.
Easy to install: Some types of shutters, such as accordion shutters, are relatively easy to install.

Cons of hurricane shutters:

Renovate to live, Sweeten to thrive!

Sweeten brings homeowners an exceptional renovation experience by personally matching trusted general contractors to your project, while offering expert guidance and support—at no cost to you.

Start your renovation

Manual operation: Shutters require manual operation before, during, and after a hurricane.
Storage: They often require storage space when not in use.
Aesthetics: Shutters can be less visually appealing than impact windows.

At Sweeten, we’re experts at all things general contractors — we pre-screen them for our network, carefully select the best ones for your remodeling project, and work closely with hundreds of general contractors every day. So, we’ve tapped our internal expertise to bring you this guide.

Impact windows

Impact windows are specially designed windows that are resistant to high winds and flying debris. They are typically made of laminated glass and have reinforced frames. Impact windows can be installed in new construction or as replacements for existing windows.

Pros of impact windows:

Permanent protection: Impact windows provide year-round protection without the need for manual operation.
Improved aesthetics: They can enhance the appearance of your home.
Increased property value: Impact windows can increase the value of your home.

Cons of impact windows:

Higher cost: Impact windows are generally more expensive than hurricane shutters.
Installation: They may require professional installation.
Limited options: There may be fewer options available for impact windows compared to hurricane shutters.

Case Study: Hurricane Michael (2018)

The devastation caused by Hurricane Michael in 2018 highlighted the importance of hurricane protection. Many homes that were equipped with hurricane shutters or impact windows suffered minimal damage, while those without these measures experienced significant losses.

A homeowner in Panama City Beach, Florida, who had invested in impact windows, reported that their home sustained little to no damage during the hurricane. The impact windows effectively resisted the high winds and flying debris, protecting the interior of the home.

Factors to consider

When choosing between hurricane shutters and impact windows, consider the following factors:

Budget: Determine your budget for hurricane protection.
Lifestyle: Consider your lifestyle and how often you’ll need to operate shutters.
Aesthetics: Evaluate how each option will affect the appearance of your home.
Local regulations: Check your local building codes for any requirements regarding hurricane protection.

When to replace your windows

In addition to considering the factors mentioned earlier, it’s important to remember that home insurance companies also look at the overall aesthetics of your home to gauge the price of your premiums. Well-maintained windows (and homes) can help lower your insurance costs by reducing the risk of damage from storms and other weather events.

Here are some signs that it may be time to replace your windows to improve your home’s weatherproofing and insurance premiums:

Energy inefficiency: If your energy bills are unusually high, it could be a sign that your windows are not energy-efficient. Older windows may have gaps or cracks that allow air and heat to escape, leading to increased energy consumption.
Drafts and condensation: Drafts and condensation are also signs of energy inefficiency. If you notice cold air coming in around your windows or condensation forming on the glass, it may be time for a replacement. These issues can contribute to moisture buildup and mold growth, as well as discomfort for homeowners.
Noise pollution: If you live in a noisy area, your windows may not be doing a good job of blocking out noise. Older windows may have single-pane glass, which can allow noise to enter your home and disrupt your peace and quiet.
Weather damage: If your windows have suffered damage from storms, hail, or other weather events, it’s important to replace them to prevent further deterioration and ensure your home’s safety.
Aesthetics: If your windows are old or outdated, they can make your home look less appealing. Replacing your windows can give your home a fresh new look and improve its overall curb appeal.

Both hurricane shutters and impact windows offer effective protection against hurricanes. The best choice for you will depend on your specific needs, budget, and preferences. By carefully considering the factors discussed in this post, you can make an informed decision to safeguard your home and family from the devastating effects of hurricanes.